Burial records from 1919 show the cemetery was divided into denominational sections, as well as dedicated areas for Chinese, Aboriginal and Mohammedan (Afghan) burials, many of which were in unconsecrated or unmarked plots. These sections provide an important historical record of Carnarvon's diverse multicultural community and reflect the social practices of the time. The earliest recorded non-Christian burial is of two Japanese people in 1903.
The oldest graves can be found to the left of the main entrance, defined by a horseshoe-shaped pathway. Immediately to the right are the remaining two graves of Afghan men, while the far left-hand corner contains the few remaining graves from the cemetery's Asian section.
A stroll through the cemetery offers visitors a unique opportunity to step back in time and discover the stories of the pioneers who shaped Carnarvon's history.
The Pioneer Cemetery gradually fell out of use due to the rising water table, which meant burials could only occur at low tide. The cemetery was officially closed by Government Gazette on 29 August 1980.
Browns Range Cemetery, located on North West Coastal Highway, opened in the early 1970s and continues to serve as Carnarvon's active cemetery today.